Storage Unit vs. Garage

Published on 11/13/2026
RSS

A storage unit is usually the better choice when you want your garage back for your car or a workspace, and a garage is better for things you use every day. At AA Personal Storage in Parowan, Utah, drive-up units start at $40 a month for a 5x10, and a 10x25 unit ($125 a month) has about the same floor space as a one-car garage.

Lots of Iron County homes have a garage that stopped holding cars years ago. It fills up with boxes, camping gear, a spare fridge, and furniture from the last move, and the truck sits outside through another winter. This guide compares a storage unit and a garage side by side, shows which unit sizes match a garage, and explains what you can and can't do with a unit at AA Personal Storage in Parowan, Utah.

Is a Storage Unit or a Garage Better for Storage?

It depends on how often you need the stuff. Keep daily-use items in the garage and move seasonal, sentimental, and "someday" items to a storage unit, which frees the garage for parking or projects.

A garage is attached to your home, so it wins on convenience for anything you grab every week: tools, the lawn mower, bikes, the kids' sports gear. A storage unit wins when the garage is so full that it no longer does its main job. Here is how the two compare at a glance.

Factor Home garage Storage unit at AA Personal Storage
Monthly cost Already part of your mortgage or rent $40 to $210 a month for enclosed units, $30 to $40 for outdoor parking
Access Steps from your kitchen 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, a quick drive from anywhere in Parowan
Parking a car Yes, if you can clear the floor Not in enclosed units; vehicles go in outdoor parking
Contract None Month-to-month, no long-term contract
Security Your home and garage door Digital video surveillance, well lit at night, your own lock
Space limits Fixed size Choose 50 to 520 square feet and change sizes as needs change
Climate Usually unheated Not climate controlled

Neither option is heated or cooled, so the weather question is a wash. The real tradeoff is money and convenience versus getting your garage back.

How Much Does a Storage Unit Cost Compared to a Garage?

At AA Personal Storage in Parowan, Utah, enclosed units cost $40 to $210 a month and outdoor parking costs $30 to $40 a month, as listed on our Rent page in November 2026. Your garage has no monthly fee, but you are already paying for that space.

That second point matters. If your home costs a set amount per square foot and 400 square feet of it is a two-car garage stuffed with boxes, you are paying to store things you rarely touch while your vehicles sit outside. A unit moves those items somewhere cheaper per square foot so the expensive space can go back to work.

Here are current monthly rates at AA Personal Storage, straight from our Rent Storage page:

Unit size Square feet Monthly rate Availability (Nov 13, 2026)
5x10 50 $40 Open
5x12.5 62.5 $50 Open
10x10 100 $65 Only 2 left
10x14 (walk-in door) 140 $65 Waiting list
10x15 150 $75 5 left (two ceiling heights)
10x25 250 $125 Only 1 left
14x20 280 $145 3 left (two ceiling heights)
15x20 300 $155 Only 1 left
20x25 500 $200 Waiting list
20x26 520 $210 Only 1 left
10x30 outdoor parking 300 $30 Only 2 left
12x40 outdoor parking 480 $40 Waiting list

The home page also shows a current offer of 50% off your first 3 months plus a 2-year price lock on a unit or parking space. Call (435) 447-4777 to confirm it applies to the size you want. For more on local pricing, see Parowan vs. Cedar City storage cost.

What Size Storage Unit Is the Same as a Garage?

A 10x25 unit (250 square feet) is close to the floor area of a typical one-car garage, and a 20x25 or 20x26 unit (500 to 520 square feet) is close to a typical two-car garage. Garage sizes vary, so measure yours.

Garages are not built to one standard size. As a rough guide, many one-car garages are around 12 by 20 to 12 by 22 feet, and many two-car garages are around 20 by 20 to 24 by 24 feet. These are approximate, so grab a tape measure before you pick a unit. Use the table below to match what is in your garage to a unit at AA Personal Storage.

What is in your garage Approximate share of a garage Unit to consider
A few shelves of boxes and holiday decor One wall 5x10 ($40) or 5x12.5 ($50)
Boxes plus patio furniture, bikes, and a mower About half of a one-car bay 10x10 ($65)
Furniture from a downsized room plus boxes Most of a one-car bay 10x15 ($75)
A full one-car garage, floor to ceiling One full bay 10x25 ($125)
A full two-car garage Two full bays 20x25 ($200) or 20x26 ($210)

Ceiling height helps too. Our units are 9 to 12 feet tall depending on size, and most garage clutter is stacked far lower than that, so a unit often holds more than its floor area suggests. Stack boxes high and use the full height. Our storage unit sizes guide walks through every size, and what fits in a 10x25 storage unit covers the garage-sized unit in detail.

What about door width?

Door width decides what fits through the opening. A 10x10 has an 8 ft 5 in roll-up door, a 10x25 has an 8 ft door, and a 15x20 has an 11 ft 5 in door, the widest we list. A double garage door is much wider than any of our unit doors, so measure large items like a gun safe or sectional before moving day. Most of our units have their own roll-up door and paved drive-up access, so you can back a truck or trailer right up to the opening.

Can You Use a Storage Unit as a Garage?

Not for a car. AA Personal Storage in Parowan, Utah does not allow vehicles in enclosed units. Cars, trucks, RVs, boats, trailers, snowmobiles, and ATVs go in our uncovered outdoor parking, which starts at $30 a month.

People search this question for two reasons. Some want to park a car in a unit, and others want a place to work on projects. Here is how each works at our facility.

  • Parking a vehicle: Use outdoor parking instead. A 10x30 space is $30 a month and a 12x40 is $40 a month. See RV, boat and trailer storage for what can go there.
  • Storing gas cans, propane, or paint thinner: Not allowed. Our FAQ lists flammable and hazardous materials as prohibited, so keep fuel at home and empty small engines before storing them.
  • Tires: Not allowed in units unless they are on a vehicle in outdoor parking.
  • Using a unit as a workshop: Our site doesn't list electrical outlets in units, and most units have no inside lighting, so a unit is best for storage, not as a place to run tools. Call us if you have questions about a specific use.

So the best way to "use a storage unit as a garage" is the reverse: put the boxes and seasonal gear in a unit so the car can go back in your garage at home.

When Does a Storage Unit Make More Sense Than a Garage?

A unit makes sense when your garage is too full to park in, when you are between homes, or when you have seasonal gear you use only a few months a year. A month-to-month rental lets you keep it only as long as you need it.

Common situations we see in Parowan and nearby towns:

  • Winter parking. Parowan sits at about 6,000 feet, so a car parked in a cleared garage avoids scraping frost and digging out after storms. Moving clutter to a unit makes that possible.
  • Seasonal gear. Camping gear, hunting gear, and yard equipment that sit idle half the year don't need prime garage space. See our hunting gear storage tips.
  • Moving or remodeling. If you are selling a home, a cleared garage shows better to buyers. If you are remodeling, a unit holds furniture until the work is done.
  • Downsizing. Moving into a smaller home or a house without a garage leaves furniture and keepsakes with nowhere to go.
  • Cabin overflow. Brian Head cabin owners are 12.7 miles away on UT-143. See storage for Brian Head cabins.
  • Toys and trailers. A snowmobile, ATV, or utility trailer can take up a full garage bay. Our snowmobile and ATV parking guide explains outdoor parking options.

When Is a Garage the Better Choice?

A garage is better for things you use every day or every week, for vehicles you drive daily, and for anything you can't legally keep in a unit, such as gasoline or propane.

Keep these at home in the garage:

  • Daily tools, the lawn mower, snow shovels, and ice melt
  • The vehicle you drive every day
  • Fuel cans, propane tanks, and other items our FAQ prohibits
  • Pet food and anything else that attracts pests
  • A workbench and power tools you use often

If the garage can hold all of that and still fit a car, you may not need a unit at all. If it can't, move the least-used items first.

How Do You Decide What Goes in the Unit and What Stays in the Garage?

Sort by how often you use each item. Anything you touch weekly stays home, anything you use seasonally or rarely goes to the unit, and anything you haven't used in a year is worth selling or donating first.

A simple three-pile method works well:

  1. Keep at home: used weekly or needed in an emergency.
  2. Move to storage: seasonal gear, keepsakes, extra furniture, and business inventory.
  3. Let go: broken, duplicate, or long-forgotten items. Sell or donate these before you rent, so you can rent a smaller unit.

Once you know what is going, measure the "move to storage" pile and match it to the size table above. Our guide on drive-up vs. indoor storage explains why ground-level, drive-up units make loading easy, and our month-to-month vs. long-term storage guide helps you plan how long to rent. If you're comparing other options, read storage unit vs. PODS.

How Do You Rent a Unit to Clear Out Your Garage?

Rent online at AA Personal Storage in Parowan, Utah in a few minutes, or call (435) 447-4777. A $50 reservation fee holds your unit for 25 days and is credited toward your move-in charges.

What to know before moving day:

  • No appointment needed. You can rent online and get move-in instructions by email or text right away.
  • Bring a disc lock. Most units use your own lock. A few have a lock and key already inside.
  • Access any time. The facility is open 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, with no office hours to plan around.
  • Payment. We accept Visa, Mastercard, and Discover, and you can pay online.
  • Military discount. We offer a 10% military discount, and no proof is required.
  • Protection. See our Tenant Protection page for the plans we offer.
  • Directions. We are at 450 N 600 W, just off I-15. See our location page. Cedar City is about 20 miles south on I-15, and Enoch, Paragonah, and Summit are a short drive away.

Storage Unit vs. Garage FAQ

Is it cheaper to rent a storage unit or a garage?

At AA Personal Storage in Parowan, Utah, a 10x25 unit, about the size of a one-car garage, is $125 a month, and smaller units start at $40. Your own garage has no monthly fee, so the real question is whether a unit is worth it to get that space back for your car.

Can I park my car in a storage unit in Parowan?

No. AA Personal Storage in Parowan, Utah does not allow vehicles in enclosed units. Cars, trucks, RVs, boats, and trailers go in our uncovered outdoor parking, which costs $30 a month for a 10x30 space and $40 a month for a 12x40 space. Rentals are month-to-month with 24/7 access.

What size storage unit holds a full one-car garage?

A 10x25 unit holds about what a full one-car garage holds. At AA Personal Storage in Parowan, Utah, the 10x25 is 250 square feet with a 9-foot ceiling and an 8-foot roll-up door, for $125 a month. If your garage is only half full, a 10x10 or 10x15 may be enough.

What size storage unit holds a full two-car garage?

A 20x25 or 20x26 unit holds about what a full two-car garage holds. At AA Personal Storage in Parowan, Utah, the 20x26 is 520 square feet with a 12-foot ceiling for $210 a month, and the 20x25 is $200 a month. Check our Rent page for current availability.

Can I use a storage unit as a workshop?

A storage unit at AA Personal Storage in Parowan, Utah is meant for storage. Our site doesn't list electrical outlets in units, most units have no inside lighting, and flammable materials like gasoline and paint thinner are prohibited. Keep your workshop in your garage and use a unit to free up room for it.

Get Your Garage Back This Winter

If your garage is full and your car is parked outside, a drive-up unit is the simplest fix. Rent a storage unit in Parowan online in a few minutes, or call AA Personal Storage at (435) 447-4777 to ask about sizes and the current offer. Garage-sized units like the 10x25 and 20x26 are down to 1 open as of November 13, 2026.